If you’re just jumping into the world of cloth diapers, you’re probably thinking, “Whew! I finally got it all straight. I’ve figured out the cloth diaper systems, materials, features, and care. Wait, now you’re telling me that I also have to be careful about what kind of diaper rash creams can be used?!”
I know. I’m sorry. But I promise that it’s not hard to sort out the compatibility of diaper rash creams and cloth diapers. You just need to look at it on the ingredient level, which is what we will do in this article.
Common Diaper Rash Cream Ingredients
Ingredients Generally Considered “Cloth-Safe”
All of the “cloth friendly” ingredients should rinse away easily in regular the hot wash cycle of your washing machine without additional cleaning measures. These ingredients are not overly greasy or thick. They are best for preventative use.
- Beeswax – locks in moisture; naturally anti-inflammatory, antibacterial, anti-allergenic, and germicidal
- Vitamin E – high in antioxidants; benefits the skin by helping it retain its natural moisture content
- Lanolin – a rich source of skin lipids
- Shea butter – effective at repairing damaged skin due to high levels of natural antioxidants and essential fatty acids
- Cocoa butter – a natural skin softener, high in Vitamin E
- Aloe vera – cool and soothing; can reduce skin inflammations, itchiness, and blistering
- Coconut oil – contains a unique combination of fatty acids that moisturize skin beautifully
- Olive oil – a gentle moisturizer for dry skin, containing Vitamin E, Vitamin A, and four different antioxidants
- Grapeseed oil – aids with skin repair, as it has mildly antiseptic qualities
- Jojoba oil – acts as a natural barrier to environmental allergens, and may help slow the growth of bacteria because of its anti-microbial properties
Ingredients to Use with Caution
Paraffin, petroleum jelly, white or yellow petrolatum, and mineral oil are common ingredients to see on the labels of diaper rash creams. These ingredients are derived from hydrocarbons and put through a refining process. Because they have a heavier, greasier texture than most of the ingredients in the section above, I recommend using these with caution on cloth diapers. Test them first (like I did with Grandma El’s – which contains yellow petrolatum) or use a disposable liner as a precaution.
Zinc oxide is questionable; many sources claim that it causes repelling and stains.
Ingredients to Keep Away from Cloth Diapers
The three ingredients in diaper rash creams that you should always keep away from cloth diapers are:
- Cod liver oil – will cause repelling and a “fishy” smell in cloth diapers.
- Calamine – may cause repelling; will leave a pink stain.
Tips for Avoiding Problems with Diaper Rash Creams and Cloth Diapers
Remember, natural fibers are more forgiving when it comes to washing away any kind of build-up, because the pores of the fibers are larger. Prefolds, flats, or any natural-fiber AIO or AI2 are great to have on hand for those times when you might need to use a particularly thick ointment. My mom, Crunchy Nana, recalls using Vaseline fairly regularly with prefolds without ever encountering a repelling problem.
If you’re not sure about an ingredient (or a combination of ingredients), just go ahead and use a liner to be safe. I’ve had to turn to Triple Paste a few times to resolve a bad diaper rash quickly, and I kept using my cloth diapers. Thanks to disposable liners, I had no issues with the thick cream transferring to the diaper.
One additional caution: If you’re dealing with a yeast rash, consider switching to disposable diapers until the rash has cleared up. It’s not necessarily the creams that cause a problem with your diapers (although they might), but you could have a bigger problem with the yeast lingering in the diapers.
Stripping Greasy Build-Up from Cloth Diapers
Oops! So let’s say that you were blissfully unaware of the problems that some diaper rash creams can cause for cloth diapers. Let’s say you smeared globs and globs of the greasiest possible ointment all over your baby’s bottom and then put on the best, most expensive, most beautiful cloth diaper in your entire stash.
Is there any recourse?
I’m certain that you can fix any build-up problem you have. I once tried to ruin a diaper with Desitin, but was able to fully restore its absorbency with just a few extra steps. (It does still have some stubborn gray stains that won’t go away, but that doesn’t affect the performance of the diaper in any way.)
What types of diaper rash creams have you had problems with? What is your favorite “cloth-friendly” diaper rash cream?