I don’t have to tell you that repelling is a dirty word amongst cloth diapering parents.
“You used WHAT BRAND OF DIAPER CREAM? Omg. You’re totally going to have repelling issues.”
You probably know that fabric softeners and ultra-greasy diaper creams are common culprits when it comes to repelling. Remember when I tried to ruin a diaper with Downy and Desitin? But how about zinc oxide? It’s an ingredient found in a lot of skin-care products and it’s hailed as a great cure for diaper rash.
Zinc Oxide and Cloth Diapers – Can They Get Along?
It’s a question that most cloth-diapering parents would like an answer to, considering the large number of popular diaper creams that contain zinc oxide – some marketed as “natural” products and some not. To name just a few, you have Desitin Rapid Relief, California Baby Diaper Rash Cream, Aveeno Baby Diaper Rash Cream, Boudreaux’s Butt Paste, Badger Organic Zinc Oxide Diaper Cream, and the new GroVia Magic Stick “Z”. Plus tons more.
More often than not, I read warnings that zinc oxide and cloth diapers aren’t exactly… sympatico. (Yes, I wrote that thinking in the voice of Flynn Ryder from Tangled. I’m putting that on my list of movies to watch again soon.)
- According to a page on the Earth Mama Angel Baby website: “Zinc oxide coats cloth diapers and renders them non-absorbent.”
- Similarly, the Motherlove blog indicates that ”Zinc is not a cloth diaper friendly ingredient; it’s made to repel moisture from a baby’s skin so if it comes in contact with a cloth diaper unfortunately it will also work the same effects in the place where you really want absorbency.”
However, Anne over at the Zephyr Hill blog makes a fabulous case that zinc oxide has been unfairly blamed for repelling. Anne argues that it’s actually a matter of what else is in the diaper cream – after all, zinc oxide is a powder, so it has to be mixed with other ingredients to form a cream that can be applied to baby’s bottom.
Zinc Oxide Plus What?
Let’s take that list of diaper creams and examine the creamy/oily/greasy ingredients in each. Taking those other ingredients as an indication of whether the product is cloth-safe or not really matches up with most of the anecdotal evidence I’ve heard from other moms about which creams cause repelling and which don’t:
- Desitin Rapid Relief – petrolatum, mineral oil (likely not cloth-safe)
- California Baby Diaper Rash Cream - water, vegetable glycerin, lanolin (cloth-safe)
- Aveeno Baby Diaper Rash Cream - beeswax, glycerin, mineral oil (likely cloth-safe)
- Boudreaux’s Butt Paste - castor oil, mineral oil, petrolatum, paraffin (likely not cloth-safe)
- Badger Organic Zinc Oxide Diaper Cream - sunflower oil, beeswax (likely cloth safe)
- GroVia Magic Stick “Z” - grapeseed oil, beeswax, shea oil, jojoba oil (likely cloth safe)
What’s been your experience with zinc oxide and cloth diapers? Leave your wisdom below!